Well, easier is a matter of perspective. I don't like the Magic based on how it works, but that doens't mean it sucks. I do like the DMX Operator, but as a starting point, I got lucky and found a bit of gear that worked ideally for starting out.
MyDMX can be quite easy. With profiles, the fixtures become very "human friendly" fast, helping to keep the easy factor.
But, you're talking beer budget, and one of the isuses with going "beer budget" route is something Jingles brought up in another thread, and that's in regards to start-up delay. Most fixtures go through a start-up sequence, which can take a second to many seconds. ADJ has some older and discontinued solutions that mainly involve a bank of power switches that can be turned on and off, either directly or remotely. The problem with this solution is the same as my idea of using a power/relay/switching pack:
You're cutting off power, so hence every time you want to use the fixture, you have to wait for a power-on self-test procedure.
If you go with a DMX solution, you have control over the light being on/off, and what it's doing BUT at greater costs. You also have the issue of controlling each light individually if you want to, or set like fixtures to same addresses, but you lose syncronizaton to a degree.
The DMX Operator comes in at the low end of the cost spectrum. I guess for a "better beer experience", you could, for the same concept(a bit more money for a better beer, or a better solution), you can go with MyDMX rather than step up to a higher end console.
But I don't consume alcohol(not at all), don't use drugs either. I'm a rarity in this industry. I don't even smoke. Hell, I'm off soda too and NO energy drinks ever!
The other added and hidden cost is you really should invest in DMX cables now. Also, if you go with MyDMX, it's worth the extra money to get the Opto Branch/4 by Elation to boost the signal. If you use a DMX Operator, you won't need to buy the Opto Branch 4, but I'd still recommend getting it anyways. In fact, I'm pretty much recommending we all get an opto Branch 4 if we're doing lighting, or else the stanad-alone unit.